Posted On February 6, 2018

Brady Is Not The GOAT, But Super Bowl LII Was

by | Feb 6, 2018 | Sports

I’m old enough to remember a time when the running joke was about people being more excited for the commercials than the game. The games were routinely lopsided and the commercials, in my nostalgic mind, were hysterical. I don’t know how true that is. From 1985 (the year I was born) to 1997, there were 2 games that ended within one score. From 1997 through last night, there have been 13 games that ended within one score. That’s an incredible juxtaposition.

Doug Pederson was Favre’s backup QB in this game

I can recall some insane championship games. The Elway vs. Favre game was high drama. The 18-1 game. The Steelers-Cardinals game where the Steelers, in typical fashion, won a game being on the favorable end of close calls and close plays.

But I’m not bitter.

Nope, not I. We had last year’s fairly predictable 25-point comeback that was supposed to be like really shocking but wasn’t really at all for anyone even remotely familiar with the Patriots since 2001. None of them quite matched the intensity of Sunday night.

The defenses weren’t impressive. Let’s get that out of the way. The defenses were not good. A record for yardage was set Sunday. Not just for the big game or the postseason, but for all games – maybe even video games, too. Brady had 500+ yards passing! Three Pats receivers had 100+ yards receiving! Defense shmefense.

The last nine or so minutes were ceaseless drama. Brady throws a ball that the humble Gronknowski manages to gracefully catch, despite his bionic arm; Patriots take the lead. Game over. Even if the Eagles manage to score and regain the lead, there will be enough time on the clock for Brady. Foles marches down the field. Fourth-down conversion! Precision passing! But when are the Patriots going to get the obligatory boost from the refs?

You know it’s coming. We all know it’s coming. Ertz catches a pass in the middle of the field and runs about 35 yards  even though he’s just outside the 5, leaps over a defender, crosses the plain with the ball still in his grasp, lands on the ground, and the ball pops out! Oh no, here it comes. Zero chance the Eagles get this call. Chris Collinsworth was drooling just thinking about this call going his..err…the Patriots way.

But wait! The whole country is shocked New England didn’t get that call. Touchdown Eagles! Eagles go for two and don’t convert (questionable non-call as the receiver was hit before the ball got to him, and, unfortunately, the refs had already charged the Patriots their one allotted penalty) but that’s okay. Just get one stop.

Back-to-back games where the Patriots are only called for 1 penalty. Interpret that as you wish.

Brady takes over with over two minutes left, down by five. It’s every non-Patriots fan’s worst nightmare. 0% chance Brady doesn’t score here. A couple plays later, Brandon Graham charges in, knocks the ball out, and the Eagles recover. The refs and the league desperately scramble to see if they can somehow say Brady’s arm was going forward, but not even they could overturn this one (expect a rule change in the off-season that says you’re not allowed to hit a QB’s arm).

The drama is just beginning.The Eagles run three plays, get the clock down to about 1:10, and then set their rookie kicker up for a 46 yard FG! No way he can make this. If he misses this, the Patriots take over with great field position and only needing a TD to win.

He nails it!

I’m still shocked by this, if I’m honest. One of the all-time kicks. If he misses that, I think the Patriots win. Eagles kickoff and the Patriots try some out-of-character trick play that backfires and pins them deep. Brady gets far enough down the field to lob a No Maverick Molecule (A.K.A: Hail Mary), the ball falls to the ground, and I’m suddenly no longer a hard cessationist.

  • Doug Pederson coached to win that game. His 4th down call at the end of the first half was proof. My friend said, after the Eagles first drive, “you can’t beat the Patriots kicking field goals.” Pederson knew this as well. You can’t expect to beat the Patriots with a lousy six-point lead at halftime. Pederson’s play calling was brilliant. He and his OC, Frank Reich (yes that Frank Reich, who not only engineered an incredible comeback in college, but also led one in the NFL. Not only that, he used to be the president of Reformed Theological Seminary). He put together a masterful winning strategy.
  • Bill Belichick is the greatest coach ever. This is hardly debatable.
  • Tom Brady is the most accomplished QB ever, but he isn’t the greatest QB ever. He is a highly talented QB who plays for the greatest coach ever with the greatest system ever. Watch the highlights of last night and see how he amassed his 500 yards. They came on short screens where the receiver then ran for 15+ yards, or they came on 25+ yard throws down the field where the receiver was wide open. He wasn’t making hard throws, and his career has never been defined by making hard throws. He’s one of the best ever and has a great arm with great touch — I’m not denying that, I’m just saying his numbers are more indicative of the system than the arm. The Patriots, if I’m not mistaken, are 13-6 without Tom Brady. 13-6, friends. The Colts went 2-14 without Peyton Manning for a whole season while the Patriots went 11-5 with Matt Cassell.

Related Posts

Recreational Youth Baseball: What it is, What it isn’t, and How to Enjoy it

Recreational Youth Baseball: What it is, What it isn’t, and How to Enjoy it

Recreational baseball has the awesome opportunity to play a small part in the shaping of America’s next generation. That’s a remarkable privilege that coaches, parents, and a community dare not take lightly. We are dealing with precious cargo. Woe to us if we mishandle the occasion! To whom much is given, much is required.

Unintended Consequences (audio)

Unintended Consequences (audio)

This is the audio edition of "Unintended Consequences," the written edition of which we originally published in September of 2018. You can go back and read it if you wish or just enjoy the audio edition. If you haven't subscribed to the audio edition already, you're...

Ep. 047 | 2021 NFL Playoffs Week 3 — TAU Roundtable

Ep. 047 | 2021 NFL Playoffs Week 3 — TAU Roundtable

Listen to Allen, Tim, and Michael make their Championship Round predictions and evaluate the divisional round. We also discuss how the COVID situation and sports were related. Here's Michael's post about gambling if you are interested. [content type=page...

Ep. 046 | 2021 NFL Playoffs Week 2 — TAU Roundtable

Ep. 046 | 2021 NFL Playoffs Week 2 — TAU Roundtable

Last week we made several bold predictions, but were we right? Will we be right again this week? Will Nick say the weirdest things or is he just misunderstood? Tune in to hear your favorite theologians discuss the NFL playoffs! Note: We use betting language to discuss...

Ep. 045 | 2021 NFL Playoffs Preview — TAU Roundtable

Ep. 045 | 2021 NFL Playoffs Preview — TAU Roundtable

This is our NFL Playoffs preview episode! Last year we got more feedback on our playoffs predictions than any other episodes. Michael, Tim, Allen, and Nicholas get together to preview the new and expanded 2021 NFL Playoffs. There are hot-takes, Cowboy's jokes, men's...

1 Comment

  1. Michael Coughlin

    Ha, good points. I remember when we used to just call the NFC Championship game the Super Bowl. It’s been a lot more fun the last twenty years than the twenty prior, that’s for sure.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *