• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Things Above Us

Missions - Evangelism - Theology - Sports

  • About TAU
    • Our Mission
    • The Gospel of Grace
    • Writers
    • Contact Us
    • Comment Policy
    • Attribution/Content Usage Policy
  • Resources
    • Before the Throne
    • From Death to Life
    • Our Tract
  • Articles/Blog Posts
    • Missions
    • Evangelism
    • Theology
    • Sports
    • Book Reviews
    • Kid’s Book Reviews
    • pSaturday Psalms
    • Movie Reviews
    • Go Therefore!
    • Something to Think About
  • Things Above Us Roundtable
  • Evangelio de Cristo
  • Store
    • Cart

The Living Logos and True Mythos: A Response to “Satanic Panics and the Death of Mythos”

March 24, 2021 by Chuck Ivey Leave a Comment

Aisling McCrea has written a fascinating article on Satanic Panics and the Death of Mythos over at Current Affairs. In it, she uses the “Satanic Panic” of the 1970s and 1980s as a jumping-off point to explore the tension between truth and myth and even the smothering effect of analytical fandom. It is a compelling read and I encourage discerning readers to consider what McCrea describes and the areas where she accurately diagnoses modern American Christianity. In this article, I want to expand on and respond to some of the ideas she wrestles with.

Every Single One of Us, the Devil Inside

I won’t presume to speak for my co-writers at Things Above Us, but I turn 50 this year. That makes me old enough to actually remember the 1970s and 1980s, including the panic caused by fears of the occult. Kids at school whispered stories of a friend of a friend of a friend’s second cousin who claimed that the tiny pewter Dungeons & Dragons figurines were demonic talismans and would let out faint screams if they were thrown into a fire. In many ways, the level of panic was worse than what Aisling McCrea describes. Yes, D&D was a part of all this, but it let’s not forget it also included Ouija Boards, “backmasking” on metal albums, and Satanic cults.

To be fair, the culture was still reeling from the Manson family and Jonestown’s Kool-Aid drinkers. There is some truth to the line that the greatest trick the Devil ever pulled was convincing the world that he didn’t exist. At the same time, we have to recognize that the very real horrors a culture may still be reeling from do not justify the overreaction, rush to judgment, and opportunism that inevitably follows.

Fundamentalists and Evangelicals and Literalists, oh my!

McCrea lays the blame for all this on what she judges to be “evangelical” Christians’ love for logos and rejection of mythos. Before we get to the interplay of logos and mythos, we need to address McCrae’s primary targets. One of the most overused, misunderstood, and slippery monikers of the past century has got to be “evangelical”, followed closely by “fundamentalist.” “Evangelical” has served as shorthand for “non-mainline Protestant” but is Joel Osteen an evangelical? Is John MacArthur? Is Chris Pratt? Is Kanye? As others have pointed out: if “evangelical” is now that wide of a catch-all, how useful a term can it possibly be?

As for “fundamentalist”, the modern usage of the term belies its origin. In the early 1900s, mainline Protestants and unbelieving biblical scholars began to coax Christianity away from the foundational beliefs taught in Scripture. You can have your “god”, a “Jesus”, and some nice moral teachings, you’re just going to have to let all that supernaturalism go. A virgin birth? An actual, bodily resurrected Jesus? We know so much better now. Or so the argument went from the so-called “Modernists”.

A group of orthodox theologians, lead by the Princeton giant J. Gresham Machen, responded to the modernists with a defense of the fundamentals of the Christian faith. Yes, the Bible teaches that there will be disputable matters (cf. Romans 14), but there also have to be certain non-negotiable distinctives for any group to exist. Machen and others were known as “Fundamentalists” for that reason, but the term is now associated with separationist, legalistic, KJV only types. Think of the townsfolk Kevin Bacon schools in Footloose. The irony is that this was not at all what Machen and his fellow scholars were after. “Fundamentalist”, like “Puritan” before it was twisted into an epithet detached from its original intended meaning.

McCrea argues that “fundamentalist forms of religion”, cling to sacred texts as true and reject what does not conform to them. Citing Douglas, she helpfully frames this in categories of “clean” and “unclean.” That’s all well and good but intellectual honesty requires us to recognize that all groups do this. Who is in and who is out? Who gets to decide? Recall that in 2017, thousands of women organized to march in opposition to then-presidential candidate Donald Trump, yet pro-life women opposed to Trump were rejected from participating. For the organizers of the 2017 Women’s March on Washington, support for abortion was a non-negotiable, and failure to affirm the sacrament of abortion is anathema. Every group has to have some kind of standard for orthodoxy. The question is simply one of recognizing a standard.

We’re All Fanboys Now

More than 10 years ago, Patton Oswalt incisively lamented the ways that geek culture was mainstreamed by the internet. Circe 2010, we could all become what the Japanese call “otakus”, obsessive collectors and aficionados of whatever obscure thing we may be into at the moment. We want everything now. And it’s only gotten worse.

The type of media consumption that rightly McCrea critiques may help explain Christopher Nolan’s appeal for some. Some might assume that Nolan films are made for explainer videos. But even with Nolan there are some transcendent moments that don’t depend on intricate plot mechanics. The Joker’s expression slowly changing in The Dark Knight as he realizes the people of Gotham refuse to blow each other up. The gravity-shifting hallway fight in Inception. The rotating docking sequence in Interstellar.

Logos and Mythos

In Aisling McCrea’s piece, she uses mythos to encompass “all non-literal or non-rational parts of our understanding of what is true: rituals, customs, superstition, storytelling, art, and transcendent experiences.” She goes on to affirm the need for mythos to give deeper meaning to everyday life and shape to the mess that our lives can be. In many ways, I have known and recognize that need. A happily nonsensical, spontaneous comment blurted out by my special needs son can inject me with joy and make the struggles of the other 90% of the time seem worth it. Finally pulling that sock out of the pump in my broken washer can fill me with a sense of accomplishment the rest of the day failed to bring. (Thank you, YouTube University.)

In my movie geek days, I was blessed to find mythos many times in a darkened theater. I would chase the high of the first time I saw Malick’s Thin Red Line and Tree of Life. What was the point of that alligator? Why does that guy have his back to us, running his fingers through the grass? Why are we constantly looking up through the trees and into the sunlight? And then it would click. “Oh, that is the point.” You quickly discover that it is nearly impossible to manufacture those moments. The “Explainer” videos on YouTube that McCrea laments don’t have the grammar to respond to Malick. It would be futile to make or sit through an “Everything Wrong With …” styled takedown of A Hidden Life.” Malick’s Christian worldview allows him, and I would argue, drives him to find those transcendent moments.

While I disagree with McCrea that the worldview of Richard Dawkins and his fellow “New Atheists” is not necessarily false (it is), I do think she gets it exactly right by pointing out that is incomplete. As she puts it, atheism is “unequipped to deal with the more complex and unanswerable questions about our world.” Sure, many will deny or waiver on God’s existence and attributes but they suppress the truth in unrighteousness (cf. Romans 1:18). Reject the Creator and you misunderstand and misrepresent His creation. Consistent, rigid atheism smothers poetry. The solution is not to pit mythos against logos or vice versa. A full-bodied Christian faith grounded in Scripture will recognize all of it, including the gospel narratives, as what Tolkien calls “true myth.”

The Logos Became Flesh

I have no desire to defend everyone who claims the name of Christ or the ways in which they have defended their faith or failed to do so. Biblical Christianity is not subject to the false dilemma Armstrong presents. It does not pit logos against mythos. No Bible teacher I ever learned from, in my church or seminary, has ever flatly claimed the Bible is “literally true.” Such a wooden rule would require me to believe God is right-handed (cf. Psalm 118:16), Jesus’s body was made of wood and hinges (cf. John 10:19), and there is an eye socket in my chest cavity (cf. Ephesians 1:18). The Bible is true, but we interpret it as it is written. Poetry as poetry, discourse as discourse, narrative as narrative. So to be clear, when we come to narrative, we affirm that what is described actually happened in time and space.

As for logos, consider the opening lines to the Gospel According to John (cf. John 1:1-5).

In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.  He was in the beginning with God.  All things were made through him, and without him was not any thing made that was made. In him was life, and the life was the light of men. The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome it.

John’s Gospel explicitly identifies Jesus Christ as the Word or “Logos” (cf. John 1). Jesus was both eternally with God the Father and was Himself God the Son. John’s inspired choice of the Greek term logos, associates Christ with the ordering, regulating principles of existence. All creation was made through Christ, while he himself was uncreated. The life possessed by Him is the light of all humanity.

Conclusion

The Apostle Paul was not content to let the resurrection deniers of his day have the last word. As he rightly argued,

“… if Christ has not been raised, your faith is futile and you are still in your sins. Then those also who have fallen asleep in Christ have perished. If in Christ we have hope in this life only, we are of all people most to be pitied.” (cf. 1 Corinthians 15:17-19).

The empty grave of Jesus Christ cannot be truly “meaningful” if it never actually happened in time and space. Do you think your righteousness can pay the interest on your debt? I have my doubts about it. If you have not repented of your sins (you know there has to be a standard) and trusted in the risen Lord Jesus as your Savior, do it now. The good, the true, and the beautiful await you, but more importantly, peace with God.


Chuck Ivey

Chuck Ivey

By God’s grace, Chuck Ivey grew up in a Christian home and came to know Jesus Christ as his Lord and Savior at a young age. He has been married to his wife Ashley for 18 years. They have two high energy children by adoption and are currently fostering to adopt more, also by God’s grace. Chuck works full time in local law enforcement and serves as a deacon and teacher at Beech Haven Baptist Church in Athens, GA. He teaches for the Bible Training Center for Pastors, writes Christian book reviews, and occasionally speaks on apologetics for Ratio Christi. Chuck is currently pursuing an MDiv at Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. Coffee and books are involved. You can follow him on Twitter @3378Ivey

Filed Under: series, Theology Tagged With: 1980s, Aisling McCrea, Christian Worldview, Chuck Ivey, Cults, Doctrine, Patton Oswalt, Satan, Terrance Malick, Tolkein

Liked what you read? Subscribe!


Views expressed in posts are those of their individual authors and may not be shared by all writers on Things Above Us.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

On Sale Now

  • Before the Throne $17.00 $14.99
  • From Death to Life $14.99 $13.99

Subscribe To Things Above Us

Sign up for our RSS newsfeed and stay up-to-date with the latest blog posts on Things Above Us!

Things Above Us Roundtable

Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Android | Google Play | Stitcher | Email | RSS

Pull up a chair to the TAU Roundtable as the writers from ThingsAbove.Us and other special guests discuss current events, theology, missions, evangelism, and sports!

The Bible Memory App - Bible Memory Verses
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Recent Posts

  • Rightly Understanding John 3:16 — Applications
  • Go, Therefore: Family Worship
  • “Antiracism” Deserves a Capital Letter: A Preview of Voddie Baucham’s Fault Lines
  • Rightly Understanding John 3:16
  • 2 Peter 1 in the Legacy Standard Bible

The Team

Garrett O’HaraGarrett O’Hara

Garrett appears to have originated the term, but not the theology, "dispybapticalvinistic-expialidocious." He ...

“Antiracism” Deserves a Capital Letter: A Preview of Voddie Baucham’s Fault Lines
Tim BatesTim Bates

Tim lives in Akron, Ohio with his wife, Melanie and two children, Calvin and Caroline. He serves as a deacon, teacher...

Reflections on a World Without Sports
George AlvaradoGeorge Alvarado

George Alvarado is an almost retired member of our Armed Forces (yes, he's older than he looks). He has a beautiful w...

A Open Letter to Afflicted Saints
Chuck IveyChuck Ivey

By God’s grace, Chuck Ivey grew up in a Christian home and came to know Jesus Christ as his Lord and Savior at a y...

The Living Logos and True Mythos: A Response to “Satanic Panics and the Death of Mythos”
Michael CoughlinMichael Coughlin

Michael Coughlin lives near Columbus, OH, and leads local outreaches to glorify our Lord and reach the lost with...

Go, Therefore: Family Worship
Allen Nelson IVAllen Nelson IV

Allen S. Nelson IV is the pastor of Perryville Second Baptist Church in Perryville, Arkansas. He and his wife Steph...

Rightly Understanding John 3:16 — Applications

Click a term to see related posts.

Adoption atonement Bible book review Cessationism children Christ Christian Life Christmas Chuck Ivey church conversion Culture Devotional discipleship evangelism Foster Care From death to life Genesis gospel grace imputation Jesus Justification local church love Marriage mercy NFL preaching Psalm 119 Psalms reformed baptist Reformed Baptist Theology reformed theology Roundtable sanctification scripture sin sola scriptura Something To Think About Suffering theology Things Above Us worship

Click the image below if you got one of these cards.

Other Posts You May Like…

Forty More Days: An Open Letter to My Neighbors about COVID-19

I’m no expert on infectious diseases, and I actually did not stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night. I have no medical qualifications to tell you what is going to happen in the next forty days here in 2020 in terms of COVID-19. Most of you reading this also have no idea. But let’s […]

TAU Roundtable logo with a gravestone left and lady praying on right

Ep. 028 | New Perspectives on Paul (Part 2) — TAU Roundtable

On this episode of Things Above us Round Table, George Alvarado and Chuck Ivey continue with Getting the New Covenant Right in Part 2 of their discussion on the New Perspectives on Paul (NPP). They help us identify how to understand the language of NPP teachers, and finish up with its implications on assurance, soteriology, […]

When Battling the Culture

Christians are in a constant battle with the culture because Christianity is opposed to the culture. A better way of saying it would be that the culture, or world, is opposed to Christ…and thus, Christianity. Many Christians seem to be particularly gifted or motivated toward ending or at least fighting certain evils we face living […]

6 Ingredients to Biblical Repentance

The following is an excerpt from my new book From Death to Life: How Salvation Works: Biblical repentance is changing direction. It involves turning away from our sin. It’s not a temporary diet of good behavior, but a life transformation. It is a turning from sin and total surrender of oneself to the Lordship of Christ. […]

Philippians in the Legacy Standard Bible: Instances of “Think”

In case you’ve been hiding under the sky☘, a team from The Master’s University and Seminary is working on the Legacy Standard Bible, an update to the much-beloved NASB 1995. They recently released a PDF containing the entire text of Philippians, and I’ve made the time to note all of the differences from its predecessor. […]

Unconditional Election

The biblical doctrine of election is God’s unconditional, eternal, immutable, particular, and effectual choice to save specific persons in Christ according to His own pleasure and not on the basis of foreseen faith or merit. This precious doctrine is the wellspring of every other salvific blessing believers experience for without election, other tenets of soteriology […]

2018 © Things Above Us

Copyright © 2021 · Things Above Us on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in