• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Things Above Us

Missions - Evangelism - Theology - Sports

  • About TAU
    • Our Mission
    • The Gospel of Grace
    • Writers
    • Contact Us
    • Comment Policy
    • Attribution/Content Usage Policy
  • Resources
    • Before the Throne
    • From Death to Life
    • Our Tract
  • Articles/Blog Posts
    • Missions
    • Evangelism
    • Theology
    • Sports
    • Book Reviews
    • Kid’s Book Reviews
    • pSaturday Psalms
    • Movie Reviews
    • Go Therefore!
    • Something to Think About
  • Things Above Us Roundtable
  • Evangelio de Cristo
  • Store
    • Cart

Compromising Calvinist – When We Just Aren’t Calvinistic Enough (Part 1)

May 31, 2019 by George Alvarado

“Compromising Calvinist.” This term has become a fiery dart in the arsenal of some of our Calvinistic brethren. No doubt there are preachers who compromise the truth in many ways. But this term isn’t primarily directed toward social gospel preachers, New Apostolic Reformation sympathizers, or even what some would call “Calminians.” The cross hairs are now sighted toward teachers who hold to a theologically balanced, systematically consistent, and historically affirmed Calvinism. This particular group calls themselves “consistent” Calvinists, or sometimes “high” Calvinists (although not all high Calvinists act the way these do). And the responding labels against them are usually “Hyper-Calvinist” or possibly even “cage-stage” Calvinist. But this group is none of the above.

I am not ignorant to the reality that there will always be those who believe they possess stricter and purer forms of any belief. But what makes this group especially grievous is that they not only appeal to Scripture to affirm some of their imbalanced views, but also Reformed history. But before I go into those particular points, let’s talk about my friend R—.

My Friend R—

R— was a man who I used to preach the gospel with. I considered him my friend. My compadre in the work of the ministry. We had sweet fellowship, kindred spirits, and often challenged one another in a way that was edifying, encouraging, and convicting. Then, something changed. Like many others who stray, sometimes a Facebook page, a book, another preacher, or a trial comes along and T-bones a professing Christian into a doctrinal ditch. I hadn’t spoken to my friend in a few years, since he was “off the grid” for a while. But when he reappeared, he had some very choice words for me and my apostate Calvinism. And no matter how much I invited him and his group to discuss their beliefs, I was only met with a berating refusal to cooperate. It was gut wrenching and frustrating to say the least. But parting ways was the best option for peace.

Since that time, R— and those in his camp have gained some ground with Calvinists. They have not only harassed some of my fellow preachers and friends, but they have won some converts too. And, of course, this isn’t anything new. But I only wish to exhort my brethren to consider the following in the hopes of remaining balanced and self-controlled before going off the precipice with these fellows.

6-Points of Compromise

So what are my historically affirmed, and systematically scriptural beliefs that caused R—, and some within his group, to label me a compromising (even cowardly) Calvinist? Here are the top 6:

  1. Common grace
  2. Progressive Sanctification
  3. The genuine, free offer of the gospel to all men
  4. Christ’s atonement was sufficient for all, efficacious for some
  5. Evidence of regeneration by self-examination (i.e. fruit)
  6. Believing that some Arminians are saved despite their inconsistency

There are more I’m sure. But these were definitely the trigger topics. However, it isn’t so much that we disagreed about these things that grieved me the most. But as I mentioned, it was primarily the fact that they reference prominent, Christian theologians in history to justify their accusations of my supposed Arminianism cloaked in Calvinistic words.

They quote men like John Owen, William Ames, Augustus Toplady and even historical documents like the Canons of Dordt, Westminster Confession of Faith, and Second London Baptist Confession. Moreover, on the flip side, I am damned together with Paul Washer, James White, and even George Whitefield for preaching a “compromised” gospel. And why? Partly because I dare to entertain point 6 above. But mostly because they saw points 1 thru 5 as Arminian compromises (2 and 5 apparently being Lordship Salvation “heresy”). Furthermore, they believed that because the Canons of Dordt and John Owen (and others of our Reformed kindred) condemned Arminianism (however that is defined), as Calvinists, we should too! And If we don’t, we are compromising Calvinists.

Before I address the 6 points of compromise above, let me quickly point out that I agree that there are inconsistent forms within any camp, including Calvinism. I also agree that there are compromises (however that may be defined) that have been made by even some of our favorite theologians. But if our goal is to be consistent, balanced, and systematic with our theology, and to be fair and accurate with Christian history, we would soon find that even the most Calvinistic men in our Reformed history aren’t Calvinistic enough by this group’s standards.

In the next post, we will look at some of the examples proposed by this group in history, which should encourage us to steer away from becoming compromised Calvinists. But, we are going to see if these events/men can stand under the mighty weight of what this group constitutes as “compromise.” Such examples will include the Canons of Dordt, William Ames, Augustus Toplady, George Whitfield, and my favorite, John Owen.

-Until we go home

George Alvarado

George Alvarado

George Alvarado is an almost retired member of our Armed Forces (yes, he's older than he looks). He has a beautiful wife, a very tall son, and currently teaches at Pilgrim Bible Church in Washington. He is also an author, blogger, apologist, evangelist, and podcaster. He loves spending time with his family and friends, traveling, photography, and continuing his studies in linguistics and theology.

Filed Under: Theology Tagged With: Arminian, Augustus Toplady, Canons of Dordt, Compromise, compromising Calvinist, Cowardly Calvinist, dort, history, John Owen, John Wesley, progressive santification, Richard Baxter, Synod of Dordt, tolerance, William Ames

Liked what you read? Subscribe!


Views expressed in posts are those of their individual authors and may not be shared by all writers on Things Above Us.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Avatarhrg says

    May 31, 2019 at 10:57 pm

    “Believing that some Arminians are saved despite their inconsistency”

    I agree with this only insofar as a professing believer remains ignorant of the Doctrines of Grace and has known only Arminianism…IOW they would be more akin to a “harassed sheep without a shepherd” than a wilful false convert.

    But for those that knowingly and adamantly reject the Doctrines of Grace, I have no such confidence.

    • George AlvaradoGeorge Alvarado says

      June 3, 2019 at 12:38 am

      Thank you for your comment. I think Part 2 will help clear a lot of this up more. But, I can agree mostly with what you’re saying.

Primary Sidebar

On Sale Now

  • From Death to Life $14.99 $13.99
  • Before the Throne $17.00 $14.99

Subscribe To Things Above Us

Sign up for our RSS newsfeed and stay up-to-date with the latest blog posts on Things Above Us!

Things Above Us Roundtable

Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Android | Google Play | Stitcher | Email | RSS

Pull up a chair to the TAU Roundtable as the writers from ThingsAbove.Us and other special guests discuss current events, theology, missions, evangelism, and sports!

The Bible Memory App - Bible Memory Verses
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Recent Posts

  • An Age Old Question: What do you think about the End Times?
  • Justification, Mercy, and Propitiation
  • Ep. 047 | 2021 NFL Playoffs Week 3 — TAU Roundtable
  • Is Gambling Okay?
  • God’s Hatred of Sin and the Coming Judgment

The Team

George AlvaradoGeorge Alvarado

George Alvarado is an almost retired member of our Armed Forces (yes, he's older than he looks). He has a beautiful w...

A Open Letter to Afflicted Saints
Tim BatesTim Bates

Tim lives in Akron, Ohio with his wife, Melanie and two children, Calvin and Caroline. He serves as a deacon, teacher...

Reflections on a World Without Sports
Allen Nelson IVAllen Nelson IV

Allen S. Nelson IV is the pastor of Perryville Second Baptist Church in Perryville, Arkansas. He and his wife Steph...

An Age Old Question: What do you think about the End Times?
Michael CoughlinMichael Coughlin

Michael Coughlin lives near Columbus, OH, and leads local outreaches to glorify our Lord and reach the lost with...

Is Gambling Okay?
Chuck IveyChuck Ivey

By God’s grace, Chuck Ivey grew up in a Christian home and came to know Jesus Christ as his Lord and Savior at a y...

Book Review — Zondervan Single Column Reference Premier Collection
Justin BullingtonJustin Bullington

Justin Bullington is the husband of Deb, a father of four, the Associate Pastor at Princeton Bible Church, a 6th...

When Should We Officially Ditch a Christian Content Creator?
Garrett O’HaraGarrett O’Hara

Garrett appears to have originated the term, but not the theology, "dispybapticalvinistic-expialidocious." He ...

Justification, Mercy, and Propitiation

Click a term to see related posts.

Adoption atonement Bible book review Cessationism children Christian Life Christmas Chuck Ivey church conversion Culture Devotional discipleship egalitarianism evangelism Foster Care From death to life Genesis gospel grace imputation Jesus local church love Marriage mercy NFL preaching propitiation Psalm 119 Psalms reformed baptist Reformed Baptist Theology reformed theology Roundtable sanctification scripture sin sola scriptura Something To Think About Suffering theology Things Above Us worship

Click the image below if you got one of these cards.

Other Posts You May Like…

Book Review — None Greater: The Undomesticated Attributes of God

None Greater: The Undomesticated Attributes of God Review by Chuck Ivey   Barrett, Matthew, None Greater: The Undomesticated Attributes of God. (Publisher: Baker Books), 2019. 283 pp. $16.99   Biographical Sketch of the Author Matthew Barrett serves at Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary as associate professor of Christian theology. He is executive editor of Credo magazine […]

Luther at the Diet of Worms

Not by Faith Alone: What is James’ Justification? (book excerpt)

As I attempt to dedicate more time towards completing my evangelistic book, I’ve adapted a short excerpt here for the benefit of ThingsAbove.us readers. As with most of my book, the biblical translations are my own. The character ‘ᴾ’ indicates a second person plural. One popular apologetic among Roman Catholic apologists against justification by faith […]

Before the Throne: Cover Reveal and Book Update

I am excited to show off Stephen J. Melniszyn’s work on my next book, Before the Throne: Reflections on God’s Holiness. Stephen is a talented brother and sound in his theology. This makes working with him a great joy! Before we get to the cover, here is a synopsis of the book. Synopsis R.C. Sproul, A.W. Tozer, […]

NASB 2020 Review, Part 2 — Direct Comparisons in John, Hebrews, and Psalms

In part 1 of this NASB 2020 review, I dove a bit into major passages concerning gender, the Greek term doulos (slave), and the Hebrew term hesed, which is mostly translated as “lovingkindness” in the NASB 1995. In the time between part 1 and now, my wife gave birth to our fourth child (hence the delay) and the […]

Jesus in the Garden

Jesus went to a garden once. In Gethsemane, He prayed to the Father as He anticipated His crucifixion. But long before that garden, there was another garden where the Son of God was. The triune God made this garden for His beloved creation, mankind. This garden’s name was Eden. The land of delight. Paradise on […]

Augustine vs. Pelagius

The Debate In the 5th century — the early 400s — there was a controversy in the church between two men, Augustine and Pelagius, over God’s grace in salvation. Pelagius essentially argued in such a way that would minimize the necessity of regeneration. He taught against men being guilty because of Adam’s sin and against […]

2018 © Things Above Us

Copyright © 2021 · Things Above Us on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in